Sirschmoopy's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Wilderness Guardians]

Subpar

Slow, Unorignal, Boring. In fact the irony you think your movie will be downvoted because of the game is backwards. If this movie had no mention of Runescape it would have done half as well.

The overall plot doesn't work for non runescape players, you made a movie about a game and people who have not played the game will not understand the movie you are trying to show them. Instead they see some plot about some knights seeking revenge cause a tweening arrow hit some lady in the dome.

Overall it's just a subpar movie for a subpar game. I judged your movie the way you wanted it judged, without my opinion and thoughts on Runescape and in doing so it hurt your overall score.

[Clayground - Actually]

Sad

The sad thing is that even if this was animated, it's still knox's style and a pretty blantent rip off. It's not hard to be orignal with clay so you might want to come up with something of your own unless you always want to be that "knox ripoff". Your choice really.

BlakTornado responds:

Say's the guy who's known for making that annoying Splash Attack movie? Why are YOU telling me about originality when you ripped off a Computer Game?

Oh well. I thought that video was funny... So I'll not mention it again.
Firstly, though, it's not Knox's style :P Knox wasn't the first. Ever seen Aardman animation's Morph? And Knox wasn't the first to submit videos like that to Newgrounds. He was the first to make animations with proper plots and characters but there were claymations of that style before he submitted them.
Secondly, this is my own style. This wasn't exactly my best short :P Or one that was best suited to me... I had no ideas when I made this one :P My other shorts are pretty different - more sci-fi.

[TANKMEN 2]

Fantastic

I bet you hate the whole "I can't tell if this is even funny anymore" thing. You have a nack for the suttle jokes that one in ten people will get and for that you are my hero.

Heres looking at you beautiful.

[Yoshi's Mishaps]

Lacking

Humor wasn't there for something this overdone. Originality must be dead on NG.

[Madness in Brackenwood]

I couldn't sit through it

My god you need to learn how to make a title. Text with a fancy font is so rough on my poor poor eyes. I stopped watching the second he teleported since it's totally defeated the purpose of Madness. You just took two popular cartoons on newgrounds and threw up this abomination.

Gnydsmelt responds:

My goal here was to make a flash movie based on Madness characters, try to make something different and not the same old gore and stuff. Even if you think it's that bad, i was trying to STAND out from the normal Madness tributes, even if it may not be as good as you would like. Doesn't hurt to try.

[Mindchamber </3]

God I should parody this.

gg sir gg

[TRACER episode 1]

meh

Animation is leeps and bounds above normal but past that it's nothing special.

[The PS3 Song!]

ow..

Totally missed a couple of those notes there and as much as I would love to give you props for ragging on ps3, this song really beats a dead horse to another level.

[Awesome Compilation Vol 1]

Good stuff

Cool that you have a sponsor but man could they not be any more annoying in between cartoons.

[Cell V.S Brolly]

Come on.

Seriously.
Come on.

S-E5000 responds:

Lol, take it you aint a DBZ fan....
Typical person not to read the comment before watching.

*S-E5000 Slowly Applauds your stupidity*